4 Comments
User's avatar
Barry Mann's avatar

This blog was awsome, man!!

Vikram V.'s avatar

I want to be treated in accordance with my 3673 page long list of deontological rules, I also treat every other person like that.

The only objection to this is that my list is "foolishness" which assumes the entire question away.

Bentham's Bulldog's avatar

But that's only rational if it makes your life best, which is welfarism. That would just be a wildly implausible version of OLT.

Remember that we modified the golden rule slightly to make it defensible.

User's avatar
Comment removed
Aug 28, 2022
Comment removed
Bentham's Bulldog's avatar

As we've discussed before, I disagree with your definition of rationality.

Welfare maximization is utility maximization, given that welfare is just whatever makes things go best. This obviously doesn't prove any conception of well-being, like, say, hedonism, but it does prove that we should maximize what makes people's lives go well.

I think a lot of people find the golden rule very intuitive -- are you saying you don't know what intuitive means, or what the golden rule means?