5 Comments
User's avatar
Richard Y Chappell's avatar

Have you read Caspar Hare's "Should we wish well to all?" - http://web.mit.edu/~casparh/www/Papers/CJHareWishingWell.pdf - I think it's the original source for both the Suitcases trolley cases and the medicine case you discuss here! Really great paper.

Expand full comment
Bentham's Bulldog's avatar

Also, I'm thinking of citing your paradox of deontology for a paper. Is it forthcoming in some journal, or unpublished?

Expand full comment
Richard Y Chappell's avatar

As yet unpublished (currently under review).

Expand full comment
Bentham's Bulldog's avatar

I have not--I'll check it out.

Expand full comment
Plasma Bloggin''s avatar

There's a slight typo in the article - in the numbered list just before the "people in suitcases" section, item 1 should have the word "shouldn't" instead of "should".

Expand full comment