> Suppose you’re in extreme agony, but it’s been reduced an unfathomable amount by a loved one. You really don’t seem well off — but this version of objective list theory holds that you are.
I think this makes sense. Having someone reduce your pain by an "unfathomable amount" is generally good. You're certainly well-off by having this. Though I would point out that presumably, this person would be able to produce a lot of value if you didn't happen to be in extreme agony at the moment.
Edit: My CS friend who was watching me write this comment says he agrees with you :(
> Suppose you’re in extreme agony, but it’s been reduced an unfathomable amount by a loved one. You really don’t seem well off — but this version of objective list theory holds that you are.
I think this makes sense. Having someone reduce your pain by an "unfathomable amount" is generally good. You're certainly well-off by having this. Though I would point out that presumably, this person would be able to produce a lot of value if you didn't happen to be in extreme agony at the moment.
Edit: My CS friend who was watching me write this comment says he agrees with you :(