See your whole first point here is that people can make patently and horrifically insane statements, and then claim that anyone who doesn't argue through the whole of morality to refute them is somehow "poisoning the well" or "holds no regard to the truth". Sure, if you want to debate all topics that's fine, I suppose, but you can also just punch the nazi instead of doing a three hour podcast with them first.
See your whole first point here is that people can make patently and horrifically insane statements, and then claim that anyone who doesn't argue through the whole of morality to refute them is somehow "poisoning the well" or "holds no regard to the truth". Sure, if you want to debate all topics that's fine, I suppose, but you can also just punch the nazi instead of doing a three hour podcast with them first.