Seems like the "wrong kind of reason". While true enough that there's a sense in which you should (for instrumental reasons) value mud if the demon incentivized it, that's *not* the sense in which most of us think we should non-instrumentally value our friends. Rather, we think that's the correct/fitting/warranted response, not *just* the most useful/fortunate response.
Seems like the "wrong kind of reason". While true enough that there's a sense in which you should (for instrumental reasons) value mud if the demon incentivized it, that's *not* the sense in which most of us think we should non-instrumentally value our friends. Rather, we think that's the correct/fitting/warranted response, not *just* the most useful/fortunate response.