Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Dmitrii Zelenskii's avatar

...What exactly is the problem with "most arguments on the matter of morals are not substantive but simply model comparisons"?

Richard Y Chappell's avatar

Great post!

I could see some naturalists try to push back by insisting that they're not trying to offer an *analytic* (or conceptual) reduction, but merely a *metaphysical* one, which need not be transparent to ordinary language users.

Even so, I think something in this vicinity -- the challenge of how to account for the substantiveness of boundary disputes -- provides the most fundamental reason to reject naturalism (about both normativity and qualia): https://www.philosophyetc.net/2016/03/the-basic-reason-to-reject-naturalism.html

7 more comments...

Ready for more?