Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Mark's avatar

>God is a limitless agent. An agent is a mind that pairs with the world in some way: this without limits=a being whose mind matches the world (omniscience) and for whom the world matches its mind (omnipotence). We’ll come back to this idea later.

This is really, in my mind, the fundamental mistake. There's just no easy way to make this work when you try to provide rigorous definitions of what you're talking about, and if there were, the resolution to the various semantic paradoxes would essentially be considered a solved problem in philosophical logic.

Aron Ravin's avatar

Agree with 90% of this, but I think both you and Scott are missing why "simplicity" matters when adopting a belief. When adopting a belief, I think simplicity is more of a statement about how easy a theory is to grasp. People are, naturally, less likely to believe what they find difficult to understand (ceteris paribus; of course there are some extremely hard to understand things that people believe for other reasons). After all, isn't believing something basically saying "I think this makes more sense to me than the alternative possibilities that I think contradict this."

Divine simplicity, the absence of attributes/properties, "how long it takes to describe something in an ideal language," etc. are not perceived as "simple." We have fewer analogies to draw on, it's more difficult for us to imagine in practice, etc. Which is why most theists historically have been polytheists, unintentionally violated doctrines of divine simplicity, or personified God (even the never-incarnate Father). People crave explanations that are easier to intuit, which is why conspiracies that posit one evil actor/org as the cause for certain events are so appealing, despite their low probabilty of being true.

Bayes’ theorem says nothing like “shorter descriptions are more rationally probable” or “ontologically simpler worlds deserve higher priors.” I think the example you give that is basically “infinite - 1” is less believable because it is harder analogize “infinite - 1” than “infinite.” It isn’t actually a matter of probability.

You guys are using simplicity normatively, as though there is some objective standard of simplicity that confers an obligation to believe something. But that seems to both A. run counter to how we actually think and B. unjustified in your pieces. Psychological simplicity seems to be the only version that is relevant in epistemology, not linguistic/ontological.

109 more comments...

Ready for more?