Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Vikram V.'s avatar

You say that you accept the immortality argument. Are you willing to test it?

Gerald's avatar

I think there is an even better response to the second objection. Suppose (as you do), that souls exist. Consider a hypothesis where God creates all souls and gives all of them the experience stream that includes first living around 100 years on Earth and then infinite years in heaven (as a toy model). Given this, what are the odds that you would be living on Earth right now?

If you assumed that your current experience was randomly sampled from all the experiences you will ever have and that you have no other information, then it would indeed be very close to 0%. But that's a false assumption! Let tn be the current moment of time (i.e. the "now"), where n stands for the number of years you've lived. So for me the current moment would be t33. The question "what are the odds that you would be living on Earth right now?" then reduces to "what are the odds that you would be living on Earth at t33". And given our hypothesis, the probability of that is nearly 100%.

8 more comments...

Ready for more?