Under the section "What can be done", I would argue that we should add #4: Go vegan and urge everyone you know to go vegan, as well. This step is arguably more important, at least in the long run, than the three other steps.
I appreciate the post and the point you made above. However, I do often wish that when you write about factory farms and the like, you would put more emphasis on going vegan, along with concrete guidance on how to actually make the shift away from an omnivore diet. Even a short section on first steps, or a link to resources (like https://www.howdoigovegan.com/), would help readers who are persuaded by the argument but unsure where to start.
Unfortunately, studies seem to indicate that vegan messaging often backfires and even produces a negative effect in these situations, so it's a very fine balance
Coming from another vegetarian, you have to understand this. Constantly urging people to be vegetarian or vegan hurts your cause, not helps it. Meat eating is deeply ingrained in people's cultural identity. Embracing that lifestyle is a massive change that people need to come to on their own. Engage with ideas and values first, and let people come to the logical conclusions on their own. Adding "btw, you should be vegan" onto every article creates a culture of animosity towards the movement, which it has been wrestling with for decades.
I became vegetarian, then vegan, partly from reading EA/rationalist/rat-adjacent stuff on and off for years and slowly getting irradiated with the vegan memes until I didn't want to be not-vegan anymore.
No other major injustice that I know of was ended by letting people come to it on their own. Sometimes it takes literal war, sometimes it takes massive pressure campaigns, but just letting people "come to it on their own" just doesn't work.
How confident are you that 1) moving the needle on this bill would have a bigger impact on farmed animal welfare than alternative causes/interventions, and 2) donating to the AMPA is the highest-leverage way to move this needle with money?
In other words, let’s say that I have a budget of $10k/year for animal causes overall. How much of that budget do you think should be allocated to donating to the AMPA, and do you think it is reasonable to “pull forward” future years’ budgets due to the importance and timeliness of this issue?
I haven’t followed this issue at all but am happy to reallocate donations. I just want to understand exactly what level of conviction you and your friends who follow it have on the relative value of AMPA donations vs other causes.
how do you know this? I've seen a lot of EAs make this claim but I did not see it anywhere on the actual donation link or any primary sources (for reference, I'm talking about the one you gave here: https://donorbox.org/american-meat-producers-association)
What, they're small meat producers that don't practice gestation and farrowing crating? Why would they be interested in seeing the successful defeat of a bill that puts limitations on how they produce pork?
I don't claim to know the answer, but some guesses I have are:
-they have a moral objection to gestation crates
-stricter animal welfare standards make it easier for small farmers to compete in the market because they already comply with the animal welfare laws, but large meat producers don't.
To elaborate and clarify, some regulations affect small producers more. Some regulations affect large producers more. I believe that gestation crate bans affect large producers more because gestation crates are associated with economies of scale.
Pigs are not confined on factory farms so they burn less calories and have to be fed less.
They are mass produced in cramped quarters and confined to prevent fighting, cannibalism, crushing of piglets, and to allow human control over a relatively dangerous animal. If you ever walked into an open pen with a mother sow and her piglets you would know what I mean.
The confinement takes away all of their freedoms and the only thing they have going for them in their miserable lives is enough to eat and drink. Nutrition is never compromised so they will produce maximum numbers of piglets and pounds of consumable flesh.
>I know people who have given tens of thousands of dollars because of the extreme urgency of the cause.
Proud to be another one of these people!
I just donated $100 to the AMPA. Thanks for bringing this to my attention.
Thank you!
Good Brother. Amen
Keep pushing friends
Is donating to the AMPA literally casting your pearls before swine?
(good idea regardless)
Ironic that something called the American Meat Producers Association is an ally! But yes, thanks for this post.
This is heartbreaking.
Your words did what they needed to do. I am compelled to act and to ask others to act.
This is sick. Thank you for bringing attention to such disturbing practices.
Under the section "What can be done", I would argue that we should add #4: Go vegan and urge everyone you know to go vegan, as well. This step is arguably more important, at least in the long run, than the three other steps.
I was speaking of what can be done specifically to stop the bill, not what can be done for animals in general.
I appreciate the post and the point you made above. However, I do often wish that when you write about factory farms and the like, you would put more emphasis on going vegan, along with concrete guidance on how to actually make the shift away from an omnivore diet. Even a short section on first steps, or a link to resources (like https://www.howdoigovegan.com/), would help readers who are persuaded by the argument but unsure where to start.
Unfortunately, studies seem to indicate that vegan messaging often backfires and even produces a negative effect in these situations, so it's a very fine balance
I think it'd be good to provide some light citations. These sorts of claims go untested a lot
Coming from another vegetarian, you have to understand this. Constantly urging people to be vegetarian or vegan hurts your cause, not helps it. Meat eating is deeply ingrained in people's cultural identity. Embracing that lifestyle is a massive change that people need to come to on their own. Engage with ideas and values first, and let people come to the logical conclusions on their own. Adding "btw, you should be vegan" onto every article creates a culture of animosity towards the movement, which it has been wrestling with for decades.
I became vegetarian, then vegan, partly from reading EA/rationalist/rat-adjacent stuff on and off for years and slowly getting irradiated with the vegan memes until I didn't want to be not-vegan anymore.
> Embracing that lifestyle is a massive change that people need to come to on their own.
I didn't come to it on my own. I was persuaded by two friends of mine and also by information I read online.
No other major injustice that I know of was ended by letting people come to it on their own. Sometimes it takes literal war, sometimes it takes massive pressure campaigns, but just letting people "come to it on their own" just doesn't work.
Appreciate the sentiment here but "literally pennies per animal" seems like an egregious misstatement when the linked tweet shows pennies per *dollar*
Seconded. One animal's worth of meat costs more than $1.
How confident are you that 1) moving the needle on this bill would have a bigger impact on farmed animal welfare than alternative causes/interventions, and 2) donating to the AMPA is the highest-leverage way to move this needle with money?
In other words, let’s say that I have a budget of $10k/year for animal causes overall. How much of that budget do you think should be allocated to donating to the AMPA, and do you think it is reasonable to “pull forward” future years’ budgets due to the importance and timeliness of this issue?
I haven’t followed this issue at all but am happy to reallocate donations. I just want to understand exactly what level of conviction you and your friends who follow it have on the relative value of AMPA donations vs other causes.
Stop buying all pork products. That will get their attention. Nothing else will.
Can you explain the AMPA’s deal? Obviously, I’m hesitant to donate to the American Meat Producers Association as a vegan.
The money they have through the pac is only spent on opposing this bill
how do you know this? I've seen a lot of EAs make this claim but I did not see it anywhere on the actual donation link or any primary sources (for reference, I'm talking about the one you gave here: https://donorbox.org/american-meat-producers-association)
What, they're small meat producers that don't practice gestation and farrowing crating? Why would they be interested in seeing the successful defeat of a bill that puts limitations on how they produce pork?
Yes. I guess the basic thing is that they don’t want their competitors undercutting them and maybe also oppose gestation crates morally.
I don't claim to know the answer, but some guesses I have are:
-they have a moral objection to gestation crates
-stricter animal welfare standards make it easier for small farmers to compete in the market because they already comply with the animal welfare laws, but large meat producers don't.
This article might explain: https://civileats.com/2025/10/14/farmers-push-legislators-to-keep-california-animal-welfare-law-on-the-books/
To elaborate and clarify, some regulations affect small producers more. Some regulations affect large producers more. I believe that gestation crate bans affect large producers more because gestation crates are associated with economies of scale.
https://youtu.be/63NNuG-6-hQ?si=4P-Dpw-t5CQrWW7m
To look on the bright side if Boozeman is against I'd place the odds they have 51 votes to pass an amendment at well below 50%.
Pigs are not confined on factory farms so they burn less calories and have to be fed less.
They are mass produced in cramped quarters and confined to prevent fighting, cannibalism, crushing of piglets, and to allow human control over a relatively dangerous animal. If you ever walked into an open pen with a mother sow and her piglets you would know what I mean.
The confinement takes away all of their freedoms and the only thing they have going for them in their miserable lives is enough to eat and drink. Nutrition is never compromised so they will produce maximum numbers of piglets and pounds of consumable flesh.