154 Comments
User's avatar
Alex C.'s avatar

> But if you talk to religious people, they will very often tell you about extremely hard to explain experiences.

The late Philip J. Klass, an aerospace expert, wrote a book called "UFOs Explained". In it, he recounted many stories of UFO sightings that appeared, on the surface, to be hard to explain without positing extraterrestrials or supernatural phenomena. But after he started digging into those stories, he found plausible, mundane explanations.

Similarly, when I see magic tricks performed on TV, most of them seem to violate laws of nature. But then I check Reddit threads, and I see how they were done.

History is long, and weird coincidences happen. Also, events get mis-remembered, crucial details get left out, and non-obvious explanations get overlooked.

Bentham's Bulldog's avatar

I haven’t found this with miracles. The more I dig the less explainable they get. What’s the natural explanation other than chance of the premonition Aron recounted his acquaintance getting?

Adam Hill's avatar

How often were he and his wife in contact with her? Suppose he had prior reason to suspect she might be prone to a diabetic coma and knew that she wasn't feeling well (people may feel sick for days prior to a diabetic coma), coupled with the fact that he already has a profound belief in God and would be predisposed to explain his own behavior as the result of divine inspiration. So he had the feeling that he needed to check on her that he may not have consciously recognized, attributed it to God in the dreamlike state one would be more likely to early in the morning immediately after waking, and then interpreted the fact that his hunch was correct as a miracle. Do we know for a fact this individual has never done anything similar believing God was telling him to do it, without the same effect?

The odds become drastically less impressive if we don't assume that he had no reason to worry about her health.

Alex C.'s avatar

As you implied, we tend to hear about the hits but not the misses. How often do you hear someone publicizing this type of story: "I had this weird feeling about my mother-in-law. So I drove to her house, but she was totally fine."

geoduck's avatar

The other day I woke from a dream with a profound feeling that Joe Biden had died. It was so convincing that I rolled over, grabbed my phone and checked CNN. Biden is apparently not dead as of this writing, but it could easily have been coincidentally true! And while calling it a miracle wouldn’t be very nice, I sure would’ve been spooked!

Alex C.'s avatar

I don't know. But given enough events over long enough periods of time, you'll find unusual coincidences. You also have to wonder why God chooses to perform miracles in such a weird, capricious, arbitrary way, where some people's comatose relatives get saved via miraculous intervention, but other people's relatives die. That doesn't make much sense to me.

St. Jerome Powell's avatar

Do you think you should expect the plans of the mind that made the Universe to make sense to you? But not to totally ignore the point, on a Christian conception God isn’t saving sick people mainly because he wants them to live longer, they have an infinite amount of life left anyway, hopefully in an infinitely better place. It’s good to live longer and healthier but the impacts on other people’s salvation are much more important. So a Christian believes that those endgame impacts are probably what determines most miracles and non-miracles. Unfortunately, this explanation will also probably “not make much sense to” you.

JerL's avatar

I'm fine with this argument if religious people are constrained by it too: you can't say "God is obviously more likely to intervene supernaturally to save a life than to end it", for example.

This suggests we should see just as many miracles where someone *loses* a limb with no obvious natural explanation as ones where they regrow them; ones where someone *fails* to intervene when they usually would, at just the right time to save someone as ones where they do intervene when they usually wouldn't, etc.

Alex C.'s avatar

> Do you think you should expect the plans of the mind that made the Universe to make sense to you?

BB is saying that we should listen to the stories with an open mind, consider the evidence, weigh the possible explanations, and use our best thinking skills to consider whether a miracle occurred. So either we should apply our rational faculties, or we shouldn't.

Adam Hill's avatar

This just raises the question of why there are also many people who don't have these experiences.

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Sep 26, 2025
Comment deleted
MichaelKiwi's avatar

This seems like one of the more easily explainable miracles. The first question I have is did he call his mother in law. It would be very strange to drive hours concerned for someone’s health but not bother calling them.

So assume he had a bad feeling, called her and got no answer. Then it makes perfect sense to drive there, especially if she’d had health problems. Then the only coincidence is having a bad feeling and it being right. But people get bad feelings and call relatives all the time. We just don’t count up all the times they’re fine.

WSCFriedman's avatar

I regularly have premonitions that specific people are in danger that are, in my experience, always wrong. Statistics says that one of these days it won't be.

In-Nate Ideas's avatar

I think it's fair to debate exactly how low our prior in supernatural explanations should be, and perhaps it should be somewhat higher for the reasons you give. But I think you also need a fairly high prior in "there's some naturalistic explanation I can't think of because I'm not smart enough or I don't have enough facts." It seems like the latter would easily come to dominate the possibility space in many instances, simply because the world is causally complex and humans have limited empirical abilities.

Tom Hitchner's avatar

Yes, I made this exact point to BB in Notes yesterday—for instance, the significance of almost 400 years having passed since Calanda isn’t that people were less honest then, it’s that there’s no chance of doing a proper investigation that would assure us that there’s nothing we’ve missed.

uenzus's avatar

This is especially true when are talking about anectodal stories (like many mentioned in this article). How are we supposed to investigate a story that happened years if not decades ago, of which we only have a single version (sometimes even a second-hand one)?

This is not to say that the people who experienced this things are lying, but how is one supposed to give an account of what happened with basically zero possibility of investigation?

At least in the Calanda case we have official documentation and multiple witnesses

Nicholas Mackelprang's avatar

You don't really need to know what exactly happened in order to rule out a miracle account, at most you just need to show that there are other accounts which are more likely to b true, not that those accounts are true.

Arturo Macias's avatar

The Calanda Miracle happened in 1637, in a deeply catholic country. How can you trust reporting in those conditions? It is almost comical!

Bentham's Bulldog's avatar

Them being catholic gives no motive for the bizarre and extensive lying from medical professionals, dozens of eyewitnesses, pollicer, his family, and so on

Arturo Macias's avatar

The incentives to report a miracle in a deep catholic country in the XVII are massive.

Bentham's Bulldog's avatar

But you’d have to posit a vast and very weird conspiracy of many different people to explain the data

Calcifer's avatar

Unlikely as they are, vast conspiracies are more likely than violations of the laws of nature.

Yishayahu's avatar

It's not a conspiracy, they all became convinced that the miracle happened and then their memories changed to align themselves to this belief.

Woolery's avatar

Isn’t this a little like saying that people being Trump supporters gives no motive for the bizarre and extensive lying surrounding the 2020 election results, including lawyers, senators, dozens of eyewitnesses, Trump’s family, and so on?

Peter Bartholomew's avatar

Considering the fact that telling a major lie (faking a miracle would definitely qualify) is intrinsically mortally sinful under the most common Catholic view and can quite literally send you to hell, it seems the fact that this happened in a Catholic country should increase our credence in the miracle, if anything.

JerL's avatar

Presumably the same logic applies to murder -- and yet, murder was (almost certainly, I haven't checked this though) more likely in sixteenth century than in most modern western countries today... So obviously the threat of hell isn't all that strong as an incentive on a population level.

Never mind that the person doesn't have to be _lying_, just interpreting what they saw which they are more likely to do in a Catholic framework if they are bathed in Catholic influences from birth.

Arturo Macias's avatar

Read the literatura “picaresca”. Fake miracles were a national industry. It is also in the XVII century, when the entire economy was in crisis by both climátic and fiscal monetary reasons: as credible as a miracle in 1995 Rostov.

Nicholas Mackelprang's avatar

I don't really see it that way because there are also cases of hallucinations or misinterpretation of what one has saw and the group dynamics within which these experiences are shared. These could also result in false testimony and would not involve lying. Furthermore, I don't think that Catholics are less likely to lie just because they see lying as a mortal sin. In general, I don't think that religious people behave more morally than the rest of the population.

Roberto Monjarás's avatar

Hey I think that claims of deception in this case are difficult to sustain but your point (which I take it you got from Muse’s comment on his piece) strikes me as clearly wrong. Level of catechesis in the average household of a a majority catholic country is pretty poor. I don’t think most catholics today have this full internalization you claim. This from someone who’s lived his whole life on a post Vatican II majority catholic country. Now imagine the situation in a pre conciliar era. I don’t think it’d have been better. Maybe hellish imagery being more present in people’s minds back then could’ve generated a nudge to your direction tho? Again not sure since we have documentation of a bunch of lies by spanish people close to catholic authorities, like the early colonists. I think you ignore another important thing , that motivated reasoning for credence in a miracle is much more likely to stick in a socially catholic setting, myside bias is widespread, homogenous populations allow for less error correction

MichaelKiwi's avatar

The most likely scenario to me seems he was injured and they at first thought he would need an amputation but didn’t end up needing it. Decided to fake it to get more money begging. Got caught at some point. Came up with this story to avoid serious punishment.

Surgeons either remembered prepping him but forgot they didn’t do it 2 years later among many people or

they lied to save him from serious consequences either because they were friends/friendly or he bribed them. The other witnesses were just fooled by his disguise.

This seems orders of magnitude more likely than someone regrowing a leg.

PS. Imagine we were discussing this in the 1600s. What odds would you have put that there would be no convincing leg regrowing cases in the next 400 years. I bet you would have said that you would find that surprising and pretty strong evidence that it didn’t regrow.

Kryptogal (Kate, if you like)'s avatar

A medical professional back then was someone who came and wore a bird mask and killed you even quicker half the time, didn't know what a germ was, didn't wash their hands, and thought that the uterus wandered around the body and that leeches sucking your blood was a cure all.

Arturo Macias's avatar

The country of Lazarillo de Tormes!

Live Life Not Behind Glass's avatar

Good thing it’s not the only datapoint lol. The whole point of the article, the title even, is that you probably know some people who have experienced miracles. They don’t generally talk about them either, so…

Arturo Macias's avatar

It is the first miracle considered. Spain 1637, a catholic theocracy before Modern Science. Is This the best example? I feel reassured.

Nicholas Mackelprang's avatar

"The history of science seems to indicate that reliance on empirical evidence is a better methodology than reliance on the kinds of a priori arguments that proliferate in debates about God’s existence. For this reason, we should prioritize empirical evidence for miracles over philosophical speculation."

It seems to me that most of the evidence you have provided here would fall under the category of anecdotal rather than empirical evidence and not really meet the standards of evidence to be taken seriously in any scientific discipline.

FLWAB's avatar

"Empirical: based on, concerned with, or verifiable by observation or experience rather than theory or pure logic." -Oxford English Dictionary

For the people who experienced the miracle, it is certainly empirical evidence. And if it had observable results, such as a healing, then it can be empirical for others as well.

User's avatar
Comment removed
Sep 26, 2025
Comment removed
Nicholas Mackelprang's avatar

Can you elaborate? I understand that in some social science contexts people's reports about their own psychological states might count as a kind of empirical evidence, but this seems importantly different from their claims about what events they think they saw occurred.

Live Life Not Behind Glass's avatar

When one collects enough anecdotes, you get data. If you find a talking dog living in a hut in the woods, you dont really need a control. People telling you that you didnt meet a talking dog, just because they decided they didnt like his house rules for visitors before he would normally deign to meet with them, doesnt really work as an empirical method. Particularly if he is an uncommonly canny and magical dog who knows the motivations of everyone in the forest whether they decide they want to meet him or not. They have the attestations of thousands, millions of people about him, and he doesnt feel like being measured. So he wont be. Because his magic is too strong to overcome in order to measure him. He has decided that these attestations are sufficient. Measuring makes the magic less magical. Or something. Doesnt matter why really. Idk if this is the best analogy, or theologically orthodox, or whatever, but you probably get the idea. One time I got into an argument with Neil de Grasse Tyson about physics (back before I knew him as an overpaid hack, who had never published any paper, larping as a physicist), and he admitted that he was teaching a bunch of stuff that was wrong, because he thought ppl were too stupid to understand any better explanations for what was going on. Frustrated and vexed by this, yet also pondering my appreciation of weasels as creatures (they really are magnificent), I added to my rosary intentions for Mary to pray that she be allowed to direct a weasel’s angel, or the angel of weasels (I wasnt and am not exactly sure how angelic allocations like that go) to direct a weasel or weasels to thwart a hubris filled physicist or physicists in order to affect their salvation, and that I didnt need to know about it, and that I was thankful for God granting this, both because it would be cool for the angel to get to do because they dont get to do much with the salvation of souls directly, and because it would also obviously be good for the physicist or physicists. Later that week I read in the news that at the moment when I prayed that a weasel or member of the weasel family had vaporized itself gnawing on the power cables of the LHC in Switzerland, disabling it temporarily. How could I forget this occurrence? what sane person would? What sort of scientist (as I was one) would? I have other examples though none so exciting for others besides me.

JerL's avatar

When one collects enough anecdotes _using a sufficiently reliable/unbiased collection technique_ one obtains data.

Asking readers to submit all their stories of the times they correctly guessed a coin flip, and then pointing to my "dataset" of n "data points" each of which provides an update of strength 2:1 in favour of the hypothesis that people can reliably predict coin flips is not actually usefully regarded as data in support of 2^n:1 update in favour of coin-ESP; it remains merely a collection of anecdotes.

Wallet's avatar

Same story for ghosts actively being among us. In fact, like half of the stories you mention seem more naturally explained by ghosts than God (e.g. the Shermer and Tink stories). Ghosts can also explain when those freak coincidences often involve bad things, not good things. I've been spooked once by the sound of knocking on my front door at night and once my garage door opening randomly when nobody was there (and couldn't be there, in the case of my garage).

If you take these sorts of claims seriously, you don't get God. You have to accept ghosts or spirits on the same sort of evidence, and then if you are accepting ghosts or spirits anyways you can just posit some good-natured spirits to explain all the miracles you speak about. Even if you think "Wow, so many miracles happen after people pray to God!" that could simply be explained by the good-natured spirits hearing your prayers, too.

But yes, frankly, I think the people who accept that there are good and bad spirits among us listening to our prayers and pranking us with randomly opening doors are kindof kooky, and there's really no good way to explain what the difference is supposed to be between these modern kooks and the cavemen of old who posited gods and spirits as the cause of all sorts of mysterious happenings like thunder or grave illness. There are tons of mysteries in modern science we wouldn't explain with spirits, so we shouldn't do so for these everyday mysteries, either.

FLWAB's avatar

Sounds like you agree there is a lot of evidence for the existence of the supernatural, and against materialism.

Chesterton had something to say about miracle accounts and ghost stories in his book "Orthodoxy":

"Somehow or other an extraordinary idea has arisen that the disbelievers in miracles consider them coldly and fairly, while believers in miracles accept them only in connection with some dogma. The fact is quite the other way. The believers in miracles accept them (rightly or wrongly) because they have evidence for them. The disbelievers in miracles deny them (rightly or wrongly) because they have a doctrine against them. The open, obvious, democratic thing is to believe an old apple-woman when she bears testimony to a miracle, just as you believe an old apple-woman when she bears testimony to a murder. The plain, popular course is to trust the peasant’s word about the ghost exactly as far as you trust the peasant’s word about the landlord. Being a peasant he will probably have a great deal of healthy agnosticism about both. Still you could fill the British Museum with evidence uttered by the peasant, and given in favour of the ghost. If it comes to human testimony there is a choking cataract of human testimony in favour of the supernatural. If you reject it, you can only mean one of two things. You reject the peasant’s story about the ghost either because the man is a peasant or because the story is a ghost story. That is, you either deny the main principle of democracy, or you affirm the main principle of materialism—the abstract impossibility of miracle. You have a perfect right to do so; but in that case you are the dogmatist. It is we Christians who accept all actual evidence—it is you rationalists who refuse actual evidence being constrained to do so by your creed. But I am not constrained by any creed in the matter, and looking impartially into certain miracles of mediaeval and modern times, I have come to the conclusion that they occurred. All argument against these plain facts is always argument in a circle. If I say, “Mediaeval documents attest certain miracles as much as they attest certain battles,” they answer, “But mediaevals were superstitious”; if I want to know in what they were superstitious, the only ultimate answer is that they believed in the miracles. If I say “a peasant saw a ghost,” I am told, “But peasants are so credulous.” If I ask, “Why credulous?” the only answer is—that they see ghosts.""

Tom Hitchner's avatar

Good old GKC! This is one of my favorite tweets of all time, with less than 30 likes: https://x.com/stevenkaas/status/165936659819544577

Anyway, as usual when he does his schtick, it's very neat-sounding but you can pick it apart pretty easily. For instance, it's not the case that we consider medieval (and earlier) sources reliable but for their belief in the supernatural. Historians don't take *any* primary sources purely at face value (no one thinks Herodotus was even close to right about the size of Xerxes' army, for instance), but consider their probability in light of other evidence. The old apple-woman's testimony about a murder may be judged credible or not for all kinds of reasons; to the extent that there arguments against it, that's not "doctrine," it's the kind of reasoning that has to be done before something is considered evidence or not.

FLWAB's avatar

Chesterton's point is not that historians believe everything they read in old sources except for miracle claims. His point is that materialists rule out the possible reliability of miracle claims from the start, due to the dogma of their philosophy, while non-materialists do not. As he put it ". The plain, popular course is to trust the peasant’s word about the ghost exactly as far as you trust the peasant’s word about the landlord." In other words, the peasant may or may not be a trustworthy source, just as historical documents may or may not be trustworthy.

>The old apple-woman's testimony about a murder may be judged credible or not for all kinds of reasons; to the extent that there arguments against it, that's not "doctrine," it's the kind of reasoning that has to be done before something is considered evidence or not.

I agree, and so does Chesterton: subjecting the apple-woman's testimony to scrutiny, finding evidence that makes it more or less credible, all that is fine. That's not "doctrine". What he is arguing against is denying the credibility of the apple-woman's supernatural claims from the outset, because it goes against the "doctrine" of materialism. Chesterton is not arguing that miracle claims should be believed out of hand, he's arguing that they should be subjected to the same standards of evidence that testimony on any other subject would be. If the apple woman is untrustworthy, then we should not trust her testimony to either a miracle or a murder: and vice versa.

Tom Hitchner's avatar

There are two premises I'm operating from:

1. Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence.

2. Claims of the supernatural are extraordinary.

I can't tell if you or Chesterton agree with both of those, but there is some language making me think he doesn't/you don't. Chesterton: "The open, obvious, democratic thing is to believe an old apple-woman when she bears testimony to a miracle, just as you believe an old apple-woman when she bears testimony to a murder. The plain, popular course is to trust the peasant’s word about the ghost exactly as far as you trust the peasant’s word about the landlord." Both "just as" and "exactly as far" seem to deny that miracles should be held to greater standards of evidence. Similarly, "Mediaeval documents attest certain miracles as much as they attest certain battles" suggests that the occurrence of a miracle needs no more evidence than the occurrence of a battle.

Similarly, you write, "Chesterton is not arguing that miracle claims should be believed out of hand, he's arguing that they should be subjected to the same standards of evidence that testimony on any other subject would be. If the apple woman is untrustworthy, then we should not trust her testimony to either a miracle or a murder: and vice versa." Do you really mean this in the way it sounds? This would seem to suggest that "I saw John murder Jane by looking through the window" and "I saw John murder Jane when I received a divine vision" (or "using psychic powers," etc.) are equally credible. Can that be what you mean?

Seth Finkelstein's avatar

But why do these ghosts never communicate in clear language? Even if it's difficult for them to do stuff, doesn't any ghost know Morse code or something like that? Old song lyrics:

"Oh, my darling, knock three times

On the ceiling if you want me

Twice on the pipe

If the answer is no"

It's not about a ghost, but the idea is pretty obvious.

Wallet's avatar

I mean, there are cases where people report ghosts communicating with them (what do you think the ouija board is for?), but even setting that aside the same complaint could be had about God, if you think God is the one causing these events. As the end of my comment suggests, I don't think either of these options provide great explanations here.

Seth Finkelstein's avatar

Yes, but then it's not clear if the user is making it up. Moreover, using an Ouija board is intrinsically dangerous, insanely so, if you really believe in a supernatural world inhabited by spirits. It's so much simpler to have the ghost doing knock-codes. Starting with something like "one for yes, two for no" is about as basic and easy to do as you can get. But this doesn't seem to happen. Moreover, isn't there a lot of incentive to be able to communicate with ghosts? They'd make great spies. Maybe some people who do it keep quiet for that reason. But it seems like someone should be bragging about it ("I found out you were cheating on me because Casper told me!"). It's more testable in some ways than "God".

mercury's avatar

This does not seem like very clear evidence of Christian miracles in particular. I feel I can just as well say "Humans generally have minor supernatural abilities. Those abilities tend to manifest in a narrative the user is well aquainted with (God, UFOs, ghosts, sudden sourceless paranoia). God is a really popular belief, so it is one of the more popular narratives for supernatural abilities to use as a scaffold, no surprise there."

To answer the question, I sometimes get sudden sourceless paranoia. It usually is actually paranoia, but sometimes it is correct on topic and timing in a mildly suspicious way.

I am not fully convinced that this is more perceived miracles than one should predict in a world with no miracles. Pattern seeking brain right? I am constantly misidentifying patterns. It is dark and I see some clothes on a chair, brain tells me I'm about to be eaten by a grue. I feel a little nervous, brain comes up with something that could go wrong. A million processes like these happening all the time, and once in a while the process is exactly correct and there really is a grue? So everyone ends up experiencing a miracle or two? Is that surprising?

I am not saying that I know the right number of miracles for a miracleless world, just that this article has not convinced me that the number is less than we observe. And of course instances of lots of people observing the same miracle (leg guy, our Lady of Fatima) do seem intuitively quite surprising even with that explanation, but idk, are my intuitions correct? There have been a lot of people over a lot of time, so maybe I shouldn't be surprised if once in a while a whole town becomes convinced the sun is doing backflips etc.

Peter Bartholomew's avatar

I have a good friend here at college who struggles with a number of disabilities. He was miraculously healed of one of them recently by Our Lady of Lourdes (I'll have to double check with him about the exact details of the story).

Uncommon Counsel's avatar

Yep. I’ve heard ~5 hard-to-naturalistically-explain stories from my Muslim family members in Lebanon, and my dad has a remarkable one too.

Bentham's Bulldog's avatar

I’d be interested in hearing you describe them!

Uncommon Counsel's avatar

My dad’s is really sweet. My dad’s uncle, who was very religious, brought him to the Muslim faith as a child — taught him everything about it. But his uncle died (cancer) at 48, and because he was poor all his life, never got to go to Mecca (one of the requirements of being Muslim). My dad promised that he would do a trip dedicated to him (on his behalf). He did this trip in 2017. While he was in Mecca, a random man — someone my dad had never seen before, who didn’t know us at all — stopped my dad and told him “Sir, I know we dont know each other, but last night I had a dream of a man who was set free, and he said to me: ‘Tell Oussama thank you’”. I don’t know who you are, but for some reason, I have this feeling inside of me that I should tell you this”. Oussama is my dad’s name.

Larry Sandwich's avatar

Met a guy, an attorney, who was otherwise skeptical, swore to me that some weird stuff happened in a haunted house, including a crucifix mysteriously knocked to the floor

Multiple accounts of Buddhists saying things like: people’s body parts disappear and reappear, people drawing visible shapes in the air with just a finger, people mysteriously becoming skeletons and then normal again, and on and on. FWIW, These folks usually just brush off those kind of experiences as a side effect of heightened samadhi (meditative absorption).

Several people I know have reported thinking about a person and then that person would call or be in danger, etc

Several people I know have reported out of body experiences

Apparently there are a lot of folks that claim to have experienced past lives

Only weird thing that happened to me was I had a dream my cat died a week before she died.

I’m still a skeptic generally but you’re right that it’s not uncommon for people to report supernatural stuff

Bruce Adelstein's avatar

In Judaism, the Modim prayer (recited as part of the daily Amidah), notes that we thank God for the "miracles that are with us every day: evening, morning, and noon." A lot of these might seem relatively minor, but probably only because we are used to them.

I have a mild thumb sprain from playing softball and making -- dare I say -- a spectacular catch that unfortunately jammed my thumb a little bit. No broken bones, and it doesn't really hurt, unless I grip things hard. It should heal itself in a week or so, if I wear a thumb brace (which I am). That's spectacular, if not a miracle. My computer and car don't do that. It's just that we are used to such things.

Matthew V. Milone's avatar

I really dislike muddying the waters between awesome things and miraculous things.

If you're making the argument that healing abilities like that couldn't arise through evolution, and therefore must be miraculous, then that's one thing--but that's not what it sounds like, and you'd need to actually present evidence of it, anyway.

Bruce Adelstein's avatar

The Hebrew word in the prayer is "nes" which means miracle. (On Chanukah, we note the nes / miracle of the oil lasting 8 days, which is a paradigmatic miracle, albeit a pretty mild one.) A corny but somewhat insightful saying is that nature is miracles that we've gotten used to.

Your point is a good one. If a person regrows a leg, that's a miracle because it does not typically (or ever) happen. If a lizard grows a new tail, that's just nature.

The significance of miracles that Matthew is discussing is that they indicated some deeper truth -- God exists, or religion X is true, or ghosts and running around doing things. We can debate the empirical or historical details of the miracle, or the nature of the supernatural thing that our probabilities are shifting towards, but frankly for me that seems like a fruitless discussion. The uncertainty surrounding both premises are too high.

My view of Judaism in particular -- and perhaps religions in general, although I hesitate explain other people's religion -- is that Judaism is ultimately an evolving wisdom tradition. (Mathew allowed me a guest post discussing this idea in great detail. See here: https://benthams.substack.com/p/the-bible-divine-revelation-and-dynamic.)

I think the idea of the Modim prayer is to focus on the miracles in your own life. This might include awesome things too, and your distinction is a good one. And Matthew's post -- discussing the miracles in your life or your friends' lives -- is a little more compelling to me.

Joe Schmid's avatar

Reminds me of this video that I recently came across: https://youtu.be/NnYiVGek3bY?si=VWXiHyRDHkavIUD0

Ed P's avatar

I appreciate this perspective. I have seen things I can’t explain and I agree that is far more commonplace than most want to admit.

Its comforting to think you have a solid handle on the way the universe works. But for all our advancements, we don’t.

Joseph Rahi's avatar

This is a very good point, and I don't think it gets as much attention as it deserves.

I haven't seen any miracles myself, but I am close to someone who claims to have seen and done a lot of them. One time I was with him at a church in another country, and someone who he'd prayed for and healed of cancer saw him and spoke to him, saying how he'd healed him. And at another time I saw him give a "word" from God to a random woman he'd never met, working in the shop we were in, something about her boyfriend, and it was clear how shocking and meaningful it was to her. Those are the couple cases where I guess I have the most "evidence", but they're the tip of the iceberg of the stories he has.

But it is bizarre that the studies they've done apparently find no large scale effect of prayer at all. Maybe it's all the people praying for "those with no one to pray for them" (which is sweet, but do they care nothing for science!?).

I'm not really sure what I make of it all. Reality is weird...

St. Jerome Powell's avatar

Christianity doesn’t at all cleanly predict that there’ll be a dose-response effect of intercessory prayer for others. It’s really quite hard to come up with an experimental hypothesis that’s actually testable and which it would be orthodox to expect to succeed. The only prayers Catholicism assures success, for instance, are the pious prayers for oneself, assiduously pursued, for something consistent with one’s salvation. There are a lot of awfully tough problems with making any of that experimentally testable!

Thomas Zimmerman's avatar

Unfortunately or fortunately, there have been miracles or completely inexplicable events with a likely supernatural origin I've experienced. I've had experiences like this Shermer's that are more like "hauntings" or coincidences beyond chance, but will stick with healing. A close family friend has eye and liver cancer. She was given months to live. My family members and I traveled on separate occasions to the Scala Sancta specifically to pray for her. She's been living and traveling since then for four years. Granted, she did a little experimental treatment and was rejected for being too far gone, but her specialist NY doctor said the probability in her case is less than 1 in a billion. Miracle? Maybe? Likely? The problem is that the more stuff like this occurs and with witnesses, the more a pattern emerges and the more a naturalistic explanation decreases. I do view these experiences as critical to my faith and hold the miracles of the Catholic church to be even greater. And every day I thank God she's alive.

Mark's avatar

Your description of the Calanda facts is still questionable, as I detailed in my comment on that other post!

Bentham's Bulldog's avatar

Did you see Ethan’s comment? Which things are wrong in this description?

Mark's avatar

Yes, I responded to it. As I also went over there and in my initial comment, we don't know with high certainty that he slept outside in the hospital (it's the sort of thing he would've told people either way) and he wouldn't have necessarily needed to riskily trick the begging license people for the reason I outlined. Estanga knew Pellicer reasonably well starting some indeterminate time after the original hospital visit (it's actually left unstated, could potentially have been a year), and while Millaruelo used that locution ("know him well"), he didn't actually seem to interact with him in the intervening 2.5 years. Rather, he may have simply phrased it that way because it had been months in between Millaruelo's deposition and the "miracle," and by that point Pellicer was a local celebrity whom Millaruelo would've gotten a chance to acquaint himself with better. Pellicer clearly did have incentive to do all of this: there is motive to fake severe injury for better begging money (as was commonplace, if not via fake amputations), and once discovered, he needed an excuse.

Bentham's Bulldog's avatar

I just don't see why we'd doubt the eyewitness report that I cite concerning him sleeping outside. It isn't as if we have contrary evidence.

Mark's avatar

Because it wasn't obviously an eyewitness report. The innkeeper didn't say he saw Pellicer doing this. Since Pellicer slept at his inn often, it's something Pellicer might've simply told him. ("Hey Miguel, you haven't come in to my inn in a while! Where have you been lodging?" "Uh, a bench at the hospital.") While he may in fact have slept outside, in reality in might've been somewhere more clandestine and thus harder to notice a fraudulent amputation.

Matthew V. Milone's avatar

This one isn't especially unlikely to have a natural explanation, but it's entertaining.

While attending my community college, I participated in a series of game nights that were organized by my church. The first one was great, so I wanted to invite some acquaintances from college to the next one--both because I thought they'd enjoy it, and because I wanted to share the gospel with them.

In the couple of days leading up to the event, I wasn't able to find them at the normal times and places during or after class. The afternoon of the game night, a few hours before it began, I was sitting in the campus's library. I don't remember whether I specifically prayed for an opportunity to invite people, or whether my lack of opportunity to invite people was simply weighing on me.

Either way, suddenly and distinctly, I felt compelled to walk across campus to the dining hall with the belief that there, I would find whomever I should invite, and I would know it. I walked to the dining hall, which was the busiest place on campus at that time of day, and sat down. I scanned the room for an uncomfortably long time, not seeing the people who I wanted to invite. I also kept an eye and ear out for opportunities to invite strangers, but I didn't notice any. I left the dining hall dejectedly, perhaps 15 or 20 minutes later.

Later that evening, I attended the game night without bringing anyone, and it was *bad*. It was overcrowded, the games that we played weren't fun, and the older adult who hosted the event was annoying and controlling. If I brought anyone, then I would have died of embarrassment, and the invitee probably would have become dismissive of Christian subculture/events/groups for years afterward. In short, I invited everyone who I should have: nobody.