There is a currently non-public project to make this happen! If anyone is interested in learning more, feel free to reach out (we’re hiring). Thanks for highlighting this issue!
The Best Thing You Can Do is give to get animals out of cages!!!
The 10^58 future people are "obviously like the most important thing in the world!"
The ten trillion insects in a farm that someone scammed the British public into supporting are a moral catastrophe far more important than everything you will experience in your whole life!
If you had one year left to live, you ought to spend it on the hundreds of billions of shrimp who are being devoured!
etc. etc.
Sounds like utilitarianism is a pathway to discussing a new unfathomable moral catastrophe every week. The only rational argument for why you should care about anything in your own life is so that you can save more shrimp. And remember, even if you do have a good argument to the contrary, a 0.000000000000000000000000000000000000001% chance you're wrong makes it irrelevant.
This is pathetic. I cannot fathom how the intuitions that get you to universal utilitarianism are stronger than how absurd and impossible these implications are.
Common intuition agrees: suffering is in itself bad to some extent, and hence worth reducing if you could do without undue cost or unintended side-effects. (Who would deny this?)
Common intuition agrees: scale matters. Two individuals suffering is twice as bad as just one, all else equal.
Crazy empirical premise: we cause (possibly unnecessary?) suffering to quadrillions of possibly-sentient beings.
Person who refuses to make logical inferences: "It's *absurd* to think that the suffering of quadrillions of tiny beings could constitute a moral catastrophe! What are you, some kind of utilitarian?"
In such a world, Matthew would not write so many articles exposing why the premise must be rejected, so one probably wouldn’t have to think it though.
But I suppose if someone wrote an article about a thought experiment where the suffering of soil nematodes was the Most Important Thing Ever, I would also deny the premise in the comments of that article.
This is like one of the most common straw men arguments I’ve seen against utilitarianism. Nobody’s asking you to give up your entire life. Bentham/Scott Alexander/others have never said that you’re supposed to donate your life savings to shrimp. You can take their arguments at a very low credence, and they’re still being generally helpful because all they’re doing is alerting you to overlooked moral causes.
You’re investing a strawman of your own. Matthew has obviously never asked anyone to donate their life savings to shrimp or soil nematode welfare.
He’s just saying that all the combined joys of every human that has ever lived are less important than improving soil nematode welfare by 0.1%. Heck, it’s probably less important than a 0.1% credence in a 0.1% improvement to soil nematode welfare. (Except insofar as those human experiences may contribute to us, one day in the far future, increasing soil nematode welfare by more than 0.1%.)
Is Matthew right about that view of utilitarianism? Maybe he is!
I just don’t care. Even if I knew without a doubt that Matthew was 100% right about all his arguments, I would rather truth, rationality, and argumentation itself than follow his ethics.
Bentham's Bulldog endorses non-physicalist theories of consciousness which do not provide any compelling reason to believe that any entity is more conscious than any other entity. Personally I prefer integrated information theory, in which even some very simple entities have some rudimentary form of consciousness but the amount of integrated information within a network depends greatly on its size and complexity. Calculating the integrated information in an insect brain is computationally intractable, however we can derive an upper bound using the Self Indication Assumption: If insects had a similar level of consciousness to humans then I should be very surprised indeed to find that I am in the 99.99th centile for height amongst all conscious observers.
I’ll point out pesticides are pretty much mandatory if we don’t want to be subsistence farming and this presents one valid facet of point I like to bring up in debates re vegetarianism/veganism.
Agriculture necessarily displaces other life and involves violence. It corners all the potential food production in an area and generally involves attempting to kill everything that is eating it so it can be harvested for our use.
There is extremely little food production that does not involve harm: scavenging already dead animals and plants, or collecting fruits other animals are not dependent on are the only forms that come to mind.
This is why Jesus gave his disciples bread and told them it was his body, to thank the lord before eating etc. The struggle for life is sacred and lower life forms must necessarily enable higher ones. Because our food is (almost exclusively) from other living things.
Ps, if you haven’t already, check out Michael Pollans new book, A World Appears. Some scientists on the cutting edge of consciousness research believe plants too might feel rudimentary pain
Vegans normally think that you're permitted to harm animals if doing so is absolutely necessary. The claim is that we should not cause large amounts of excess suffering for trivial reasons.
I appreciate both the response and the harm reduction argument. The latter is why i am passionate about oyster farming and have limited my meat consumption.
Fwiw, I agree we should develop less harmful pesticides that cause less suffering (and better yet agricultural methods that require less killing.)
Unfortunately there is zero incentive but the ethical one and so its unlikely to occur any time soon without better recognition we need to protect that life to sustain our planet too.
There is a currently non-public project to make this happen! If anyone is interested in learning more, feel free to reach out (we’re hiring). Thanks for highlighting this issue!
Humane Pesticides Are Massively Morally Urgent!!!
The Best Thing You Can Do is give to get animals out of cages!!!
The 10^58 future people are "obviously like the most important thing in the world!"
The ten trillion insects in a farm that someone scammed the British public into supporting are a moral catastrophe far more important than everything you will experience in your whole life!
If you had one year left to live, you ought to spend it on the hundreds of billions of shrimp who are being devoured!
etc. etc.
Sounds like utilitarianism is a pathway to discussing a new unfathomable moral catastrophe every week. The only rational argument for why you should care about anything in your own life is so that you can save more shrimp. And remember, even if you do have a good argument to the contrary, a 0.000000000000000000000000000000000000001% chance you're wrong makes it irrelevant.
This is pathetic. I cannot fathom how the intuitions that get you to universal utilitarianism are stronger than how absurd and impossible these implications are.
There are, in fact, a lot of things in the world that are important.
And none of the five things I listed are one of them.
It’s reasonable for people to think people are the most important thing in the world. In fact, it’s moral chaos not to.
Common intuition agrees: suffering is in itself bad to some extent, and hence worth reducing if you could do without undue cost or unintended side-effects. (Who would deny this?)
Common intuition agrees: scale matters. Two individuals suffering is twice as bad as just one, all else equal.
Crazy empirical premise: we cause (possibly unnecessary?) suffering to quadrillions of possibly-sentient beings.
Person who refuses to make logical inferences: "It's *absurd* to think that the suffering of quadrillions of tiny beings could constitute a moral catastrophe! What are you, some kind of utilitarian?"
I deny the first premise.
Would you deny premise 1 if you didn't as a matter of fact happen to live in a world where we cause huge amounts of suffering to other beings?
In such a world, Matthew would not write so many articles exposing why the premise must be rejected, so one probably wouldn’t have to think it though.
But I suppose if someone wrote an article about a thought experiment where the suffering of soil nematodes was the Most Important Thing Ever, I would also deny the premise in the comments of that article.
This is like one of the most common straw men arguments I’ve seen against utilitarianism. Nobody’s asking you to give up your entire life. Bentham/Scott Alexander/others have never said that you’re supposed to donate your life savings to shrimp. You can take their arguments at a very low credence, and they’re still being generally helpful because all they’re doing is alerting you to overlooked moral causes.
You’re investing a strawman of your own. Matthew has obviously never asked anyone to donate their life savings to shrimp or soil nematode welfare.
He’s just saying that all the combined joys of every human that has ever lived are less important than improving soil nematode welfare by 0.1%. Heck, it’s probably less important than a 0.1% credence in a 0.1% improvement to soil nematode welfare. (Except insofar as those human experiences may contribute to us, one day in the far future, increasing soil nematode welfare by more than 0.1%.)
Is Matthew right about that view of utilitarianism? Maybe he is!
I just don’t care. Even if I knew without a doubt that Matthew was 100% right about all his arguments, I would rather truth, rationality, and argumentation itself than follow his ethics.
https://forum.effectivealtruism.org/posts/EcCW8L7ej47sCgo4k/purchase-fuzzies-and-utilons-separately-eliezer-yudkowsky
Appreciate Yudkowsky’s sentiments about a 20:1 ratio, but the value of utilons is 0, since the process that assigns them is manifestly absurd.
Bentham's Bulldog endorses non-physicalist theories of consciousness which do not provide any compelling reason to believe that any entity is more conscious than any other entity. Personally I prefer integrated information theory, in which even some very simple entities have some rudimentary form of consciousness but the amount of integrated information within a network depends greatly on its size and complexity. Calculating the integrated information in an insect brain is computationally intractable, however we can derive an upper bound using the Self Indication Assumption: If insects had a similar level of consciousness to humans then I should be very surprised indeed to find that I am in the 99.99th centile for height amongst all conscious observers.
In my article on Pascal's Wager I discuss how the Self Indication Assumption is required in order to for utilitarianism to make sense. https://angelarichardson842599.substack.com/p/on-pascals-wager?utm_source=share&utm_medium=android&r=qryqt
I’ll point out pesticides are pretty much mandatory if we don’t want to be subsistence farming and this presents one valid facet of point I like to bring up in debates re vegetarianism/veganism.
Agriculture necessarily displaces other life and involves violence. It corners all the potential food production in an area and generally involves attempting to kill everything that is eating it so it can be harvested for our use.
There is extremely little food production that does not involve harm: scavenging already dead animals and plants, or collecting fruits other animals are not dependent on are the only forms that come to mind.
This is why Jesus gave his disciples bread and told them it was his body, to thank the lord before eating etc. The struggle for life is sacred and lower life forms must necessarily enable higher ones. Because our food is (almost exclusively) from other living things.
Ps, if you haven’t already, check out Michael Pollans new book, A World Appears. Some scientists on the cutting edge of consciousness research believe plants too might feel rudimentary pain
Vegans normally think that you're permitted to harm animals if doing so is absolutely necessary. The claim is that we should not cause large amounts of excess suffering for trivial reasons.
I appreciate both the response and the harm reduction argument. The latter is why i am passionate about oyster farming and have limited my meat consumption.
Fwiw, I agree we should develop less harmful pesticides that cause less suffering (and better yet agricultural methods that require less killing.)
Unfortunately there is zero incentive but the ethical one and so its unlikely to occur any time soon without better recognition we need to protect that life to sustain our planet too.
Cheers
But why is our remaining alive absolutely necessary?
The proposition that an ant experiences morally relevant pain is less probable than that a miracle happened at Fatima.
Readers have added important background context:
1. This person believes an agent imposing eternal conscious torment is not immoral.
Now that is something I find even less probable, that suffering is only ultimately morally relevant if someone is a Catholic!