Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Age of Infovores's avatar

Good piece. Funnily enough I wrote a post just a few weeks ago critiquing Case Against Education, not because it isn’t a good book, but because people in the blogosphere seem to think it’s a total knockdown argument that proves education is all signaling when what he actually claims in the book is that someone who shares his extreme priors should want to cut 80% and those who don’t should cut 20%.

But as time passes, the caveats all fade, and people forget there were ever any limitations or meaningful debates to be had at all.

https://infovores.substack.com/p/attention-caplanites-school-is-less

Expand full comment
Mike Hind's avatar

This is a superb article - thank you for clearly articulating an intuition thar constantly nags me.

Rhetoric must be one of the worst inventions humans have ever come up with. I have an off-the-scale stubborn friend who will respond to observations & speculations with a beautifully constructed quotation from some historic intellectual or artist, as if that settles the matter. I have no idea how to navigate this move and so discussion simply ends at that point.

(Also, just a word of encouragement - you're shaping up to be a very 'good' writer and one of the qualities of 'good' - in this sense - is the honesty and awareness you're demonstrating here. Keep going.)

Expand full comment
4 more comments...

No posts