65 Comments
User's avatar
Kevin Hirn's avatar

Number 50 is a basic IQ test. Megafaunal extinction (often of entire ecosystems of weird and glorious fauna) in New Zealand, Australia, and the Americas closely track initial human arrivals. Each of those animals had survived for millions of years, across dozens of individual ice ages, which included sudden climate shocks far beyond anything current climate change offers. The suggestion that climate change is a vital component to those extinctions is often offered with minimal evidence, almost as a ritual repetition, and fails any test of logical reasoning.

Daniel Muñoz's avatar

Wow, great to know about the failure of *When Prophecy Fails*.

More generally, congrats on the new job!

June Kur's avatar

The mirror life thing is a credible hypothesis and I agree that we do need to keep tabs on it and enact preventative measures, but there is by no means a consensus that it would be as catastrophic as people say; in fact, the apocalyptic view is a minority opinion among researchers.

It’s not just their genetic structure that would be mirrored in terms of chirality; it’s everything. It’s their metabolic structures, and what they’re able to metabolize. I think the most likely outcome of a mirror life outbreak is that its population would starve due to a lack of digestible resources.

Moreover, mirror life is not something anyone has the ability to synthesize, even if some crazy scientist wanted to. If someone successfully made mirror life from scratch, the most appropriate response would be “YOU CREATED LIFE FROM SCRATCH??” We should start worrying about it once we demonstrate laboratory abiogenesis. There are legitimate and severe concerns and I understand that 10 people working on safety doesn’t sound sufficient, but given the timescale and probability of this problem I think it’s an adequate allocation of resources.

Daniel Davies's avatar

Congrats on your new job and thanks for the interesting list! A bit of a nitpick, but I'd say a way of more accurately stating #12 (Charity is unbelievably effective) is, *some* charity is unbelievably effective.

Edit: and the link to the #29 suggests that normal fruit flies "lack [capsaicin] receptors and, as a result, can eat jalapeños without consequence" and that normal flies eat spicy food "readily"; it's the transgenic flies with human capsaicin receptors that starved to death rathe than eat the spicy food.

hypnosifl's avatar

On claim 50, although humans are likely to have been the cause of most megafauna extinctions around the end of the Pleistocene, the problem may not have been hunting but rather that humans used fire, and this led to a great increase in the frequency of wildfires. This theory is based on core samples in a lake near the La Brea tar pits, which found a huge increase in charcoal at the same time as the big loss of megafauna around 13,000 years ago--more info in the paper at https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.abo3594 with an article at https://newsroom.ucla.edu/releases/wildfires-pleistocene-epoch-extinction-megafauna-southern-california though a commentary on the paper at https://www.researchgate.net/publication/375001383_Sedimentary_charcoal_does_not_implicate_humans_in_Rancholabrean_megafauna_extirpation argues against the idea that the charcoal increase was anthropogenic.

Natalie's avatar

This is almost TOO interesting. I feel like I need to spend a week on each of these things to truly absorb them

Graeme's avatar

On child mortality - weird how there’s estimates from Sweden 50-60 years before any other country.

Richard Y Chappell's avatar

Congrats!

Mark's avatar

Congrats, Matthew! :) Big fan of Forethought's work myself. Any particular subfield of their longtermist AGI preparedness stuff that you'll be focusing on first?

Silas Abrahamsen's avatar

Wpw, congrats on the job!!

JesusDeSivar's avatar

Congratulations on the job! Well-deserved.

Thanks for linking to Oks blog, as I learned a lot from it.

But I think that we should be careful to *recognize* the systematic inaccuracy of statistics from poorer countries, without *overstimating* the "fakeness" of GDP.

After all, if GDP numbers (and population numbers) were to be *completely* fake, then there would be few reason to believe that most of the progress in the world is real, such as declining poverty, etc...

I believe that:

(1) GDP numbers of the poorer countries are *very unreliable*, but they are not *completely fake*.

In Oks blog, he argued that GDP numbers for some poor countries *decades ago* were described as basically as good as random numbers. But his argument is that *now* they are as good as "educated guesses". This suggests that there *has* been an improvement in the statistical capacity of even the poorer countries!

In fact, I believe that according to Pareto's law, even if those poor countries have only 20% of the statistical capacity of the rich countries, they might still get 80% of the results right.

Examples such as the country that recalculated GDP by 100% overnight have to be outliers. After all, politicians really care about making GDP growth *now* seem higher than it really is, so it's not on their self-interest to let the statistical agencies become so degraded on their capacities as to *underestimate* GDP by 50%.

(2) Most importantly, even if the headline number has a 20%+ margin of error (or even a 50%+), as long as the number has been measured *consistently*, then the *trend* is real (declining poverty, etc...)

Radek's avatar

There was a HUUUUUGGGGGEEEE literature on #5 in the 80s and 90s. Consensus: conditional but not absolute convergence

I-1's avatar

Congratulations👏🏻

In-Nate Ideas's avatar

Congrats!

Ben Schulz's avatar

In regards to #23.

David Manheim & Anders Sandberg, What is the upper limit of value? - PhilArchive https://share.google/U1q2FrKsIXGC8ZDOv

Ben Schulz's avatar

Congratulations and good luck.